Home Nigeria Democracy under siege: Why the APC may find it difficult to escape...

Democracy under siege: Why the APC may find it difficult to escape the blame for Nigeria’s rising political violence

49
0

thecable.ng

As the 2027 general election approaches, Nigeria’s political temperature is rising in dangerous ways. From Lagos to Delta, from Katsina to Enugu, from Kebbi to Abuja, violent attacks on opponents’ campaign rallies, peaceful assemblies and convoys have become a recurring feature of the political landscape. Although the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) also claims that its own supporters have been attacked — most notably the reported burning of a campaign vehicle in Governor Dikko Radda’s convoy in Katsina — the scales of public opinion have not balanced out. For the incumbent, a stark reality is emerging: regardless of who physically carries out the violence, the public and international observers instinctively assign responsibility to the center of power. This logic of blame is rooted not only in the accumulation of incidents but in a deeper suspicion about the neutrality of the state apparatus. When violence occurs both in the streets and in the courts, the All Progressives Congress – APC’s task of exonerating itself from the public accusation of tolerating, or even orchestrating, political violence becomes nearly impossible — and this is pushing Nigeria’s democratic credentials onto the international chopping block.

A democracy cannot thrive where political participation becomes an exercise in fear, where opposition supporters must look over their shoulders before attending a rally, and where peaceful political gatherings are increasingly exposed to intimidation, violence and destruction. Democracy is founded on the freedom to associate, assemble, express political opinions and compete for public support without fear of persecution. Anything that threatens these fundamental freedoms undermines the very essence of democratic governance.

Unfortunately, as Nigeria inches towards the 2027 general elections, the growing incidents of violence associated with political activities are becoming a source of serious concern. From Lagos to Delta, Katsina, Kebbi to other parts of the country, reports of attacks, disruptions of political gatherings and confrontations involving supporters of rival political parties are beginning to paint an unsettling picture of the country’s democratic environment.

What makes the situation particularly troubling is the frequency with which opposition political activities appear to be targeted. The recent attacks on the campaign activities of the Nigerian Democratic Congress (NDC), particularly in Lagos and Delta states, have raised questions about the ability and willingness of those in positions of authority to guarantee a level playing field for all political parties.

In Lagos, suspected hoodlums reportedly invaded a gathering organised by NDC supporters in Oregun on November 12, disrupting proceedings and attacking participants and journalists. In Delta State, violence during an NDC mobilisation exercise in Asaba on November 7 resulted in one death and five injuries, according to the police. Another reported attack occurred during the party’s mobilisation exercise in Okpai, Ndokwa East Local Government Area. These incidents are not isolated matters that should be dismissed as ordinary disagreements among political supporters. They raise fundamental questions about political tolerance, public safety and the credibility of the electoral process.

Indeed, the situation has attracted national attention, with the House of Representatives resolving to investigate the increasing incidents of political violence ahead of the elections.

It is, however, important to acknowledge that the ruling APC has not been spared the ugly consequences of political violence. In Katsina State, supporters of the party travelling towards Governor Dikko Radda’s campaign rally were reportedly attacked in Yankara, with a vehicle belonging to a political support network set ablaze and several people injured. There were also reports of attacks on APC campaign convoys in Malumfashi.

The Katsina State Government subsequently disputed the suggestion that the Yankara incident was connected to the governor’s campaign rally, attributing the disturbance to a disagreement involving a religious procession. The police, meanwhile, arrested three suspects and described the incident as suspected political thuggery. Whatever the eventual findings, the incident demonstrates that political violence is not exclusive to any one political party. No party should be subjected to it, and no party should benefit from it.

The burden of incumbency

However, there is a fundamental difference between the responsibilities of the ruling party and those of opposition parties when it comes to preventing political violence.

The ruling party controls the machinery of government. Its members occupy positions of authority at the federal and state levels, and its governments have significant influence over the security architecture responsible for maintaining law and order. Consequently, it carries a greater institutional responsibility to ensure that every Nigerian, irrespective of political affiliation, can exercise their democratic rights without intimidation. Section 83 subsection 4 (and even the preceeding subsections) of the Police Act – 2020 is very clear on this.

This is where the APC may find it particularly difficult to extricate itself from the perception of complicity in the growing climate of political intolerance.

Let me be clear: the fact that an attack occurs in an APC-controlled state does not automatically establish that the ruling party sponsored it. Neither should allegations against APC members be treated as proven facts without credible investigations. Political opponents must also be prepared to provide evidence rather than rely solely on accusations.

Nevertheless, the ruling party must understand that public perception is an important component of democratic legitimacy. When opposition gatherings are repeatedly disrupted in states controlled by the ruling party, and the perpetrators are not swiftly identified and prosecuted, suspicions naturally arise about the willingness of the authorities to protect political pluralism.

In politics, perception can sometimes become as consequential as established facts, particularly when public confidence in institutions is already fragile.

The APC cannot simply dismiss these concerns as opposition propaganda. It must demonstrate, through concrete action, that it is committed to protecting the democratic rights of all Nigerians, including those who seek to replace it at the ballot box.

Indeed, the responsibility of an incumbent government is not merely to secure its political stronghold or provide protection for its candidates. It is to guarantee the safety of every political actor, including those whose political ambitions are directly opposed to its interests.

The security agencies must rise above partisan considerations

One of the most disappointing aspects of the unfolding situation is the apparent inability to guarantee adequate security for political gatherings.

Advertisement

The Nigeria Police Force, in particular, has a constitutional responsibility to maintain public order, prevent crime and protect lives and property, reference to above-mentioned section 83(4) of the Police Act 2020. Political gatherings, whether organised by the ruling party or the opposition, should receive adequate security protection.

It is unacceptable that citizens should have to calculate the possibility of being attacked before attending a political meeting. Equally unacceptable is the prospect of political candidates being prevented from reaching their supporters because of intimidation by individuals or groups who believe they have the right to determine who can campaign in a particular community.

Advertisement

The police must not be seen as an instrument of political convenience. Their constitutional responsibility is to the Nigerian state and its citizens, not to the political interests of whoever happens to occupy the corridors of power.

Where intelligence suggests that a political gathering could be disrupted, the appropriate response should be preventive security measures, not merely issuing warnings and subsequently explaining why violence occurred.

More importantly, arrests must lead to credible investigations and prosecution. The practice of making arrests after high-profile incidents, only for the public to hear little or nothing about the eventual outcome, does not inspire confidence.

The federal and state governments must also recognise that their responsibility extends beyond issuing condemnations. They must ensure that the perpetrators of political violence, irrespective of their political connections, are brought to justice.

The courtroom must not become another battlefield

Beyond the physical attacks on political gatherings, there is another dimension of the unfolding democratic crisis that deserves equal attention: the increasing tendency for political disputes to find their way into the courtroom, with potentially far-reaching consequences for opposition parties.

The recent judgment of the Federal High Court in Abuja concerning the leadership of the African Democratic Congress (ADC), led by former Senate President David Mark, is a case in point.

On November 5, 2026, the court nullified the Mark-led caretaker committee and invalidated decisions taken under its leadership, including the party’s presidential primary that produced former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar as its candidate, as well as the nominations of other candidates for the 2027 elections.

The case followed a suit instituted by Nafiu Bala Gombe, a former deputy national chairman of the party, challenging the process through which the caretaker committee assumed control of its affairs.

Of course, the judiciary has a constitutional responsibility to interpret the law and resolve disputes. Political parties are not above the law, and their internal affairs must comply with applicable legal provisions. Neither should the judiciary be expected to validate an illegitimate process simply because a political party is involved.

However, the broader implications of such judicial interventions deserve careful consideration, particularly when their consequences could determine whether an opposition party is able to participate effectively in an impending general election.

There is a critical distinction between judicial independence and the public perception of judicial impartiality. The former is a constitutional requirement; while the latter is essential to public confidence in the justice system.

Where political disputes result in court decisions that fundamentally alter party leadership structures or invalidate candidates, the judiciary must be prepared to demonstrate that its decisions are anchored firmly in the law, due process and the evidence presented before it.

It is equally important that political parties resolve their internal disagreements through lawful and transparent procedures rather than turning their organisations into theatres of endless litigation.

Nevertheless, the judiciary must remain conscious of the democratic implications of its decisions. The courtroom should be a place where justice is dispensed, not an arena where political competition is inadvertently narrowed through procedural uncertainty or avoidable delays.

Ultimately, the legitimacy of judicial decisions rests on the law, not on whether their consequences favour the ruling party or the opposition.

Nigeria’s democratic image is at stake

Perhaps the most damaging consequence of this emerging situation is the impression it creates about Nigeria before the international community. Nigeria is Africa’s most populous country and one of the continent’s most consequential democracies. Its political development is closely watched, particularly by countries and institutions that regard it as an important reference point for democratic governance in Africa.

After more than 27 years of uninterrupted civilian rule since 1999, Nigerians should reasonably expect a more mature democratic culture, one in which political disagreements are settled through persuasion, negotiation, public debate and the ballot box rather than violence and intimidation.

Yet, the recurrence of political violence raises uncomfortable questions about how much progress we have actually made in consolidating our democratic institutions.

For international observers, development partners, diplomatic missions and democracy-monitoring organisations, the safety of political candidates, journalists, party supporters and voters is an important indicator of the credibility of an electoral process.

An election is not credible simply because voting takes place on the scheduled date or because results are eventually announced by the electoral commission. Credibility begins long before election day.

It begins with the freedom of political parties to organise, the ability of candidates to campaign across communities, the safety of supporters attending political gatherings and the confidence of citizens that their political choices will not expose them to violence.

When these conditions are absent, the electoral process becomes fundamentally compromised, even before a single ballot is cast.

Nigeria must also understand that its international democratic reputation has implications beyond political symbolism. It affects the country’s diplomatic standing, its influence in regional and continental affairs, and the confidence of international institutions in its democratic commitments.

A country that seeks to exercise leadership in Africa must be prepared to demonstrate the democratic values it advocates.

The danger of normalising political thuggery

There is another danger that should worry every well-meaning Nigerian: the gradual normalisation of political violence.

When supporters of rival parties begin to regard physical confrontation as an acceptable expression of political loyalty, the foundations of democratic coexistence are weakened.

Political parties are not armies, and their supporters are not combatants. A political rally is not a military operation, while an opposition candidate is not an enemy of the state.

Unfortunately, the desperation to capture or retain political power has, over the years, encouraged a culture in which some politicians see political thugs as useful instruments for intimidating opponents, disrupting gatherings and controlling political territories.

This culture must end.

Politicians who recruit, finance or encourage violent groups must understand that they are not merely creating problems for their opponents. They are undermining the same democratic system through which they seek political legitimacy.

There is also a responsibility on political leaders to rein in their supporters. Political communication should not be reduced to inflammatory rhetoric, personal attacks and language that portrays opponents as enemies who must be defeated by every conceivable means.

The ability to tolerate opposing political views is one of the clearest indications of democratic maturity.

A politician who cannot tolerate criticism or allow an opponent to address a gathering in his political stronghold has fundamentally misunderstood the meaning of democracy.

The way forward

With the 2027 general elections approaching] , there is an urgent need for decisive intervention.

First, the federal and state governments must publicly and unequivocally commit to protecting the political rights of every party. Such commitments must translate into practical security arrangements for campaign rallies, town hall meetings, political processions and other lawful gatherings.

Second, the police and other security agencies must investigate reported attacks impartially and ensure that those responsible are prosecuted, regardless of their political affiliations or connections.

Third, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), in collaboration with security agencies and relevant stakeholders, must strengthen mechanisms for monitoring political violence and responding promptly to threats against electoral activities.

Fourth, political parties must commit themselves to peaceful campaigns, discourage provocative rhetoric and discipline members who engage in violence. The proposed peace accord involving political parties in Katsina, for instance, should be translated into measurable commitments and not become another ceremonial document that gathers dust after the cameras are switched off.

Finally, the judiciary must continue to uphold the rule of law while ensuring that political disputes are resolved transparently, fairly and without unnecessary delays that could undermine electoral participation.

The international community, civil society organisations and the media also have important roles to play in monitoring the electoral environment, documenting violations and demanding accountability.

A democracy must accommodate dissent

Ultimately, the strength of a democracy is not measured by how comfortably the ruling party exercises power, but by how safely those who disagree with it can express their views and seek to replace it. Any democracy that does not tolerate dissents is a parody of the system.

The opposition is not an inconvenience to democracy. It is an indispensable component of it. Its existence provides citizens with alternatives, encourages accountability and prevents the concentration of political power without meaningful scrutiny.

This is why the APC must be particularly conscious of the perception that it is benefiting from, or failing to adequately address, an increasingly hostile political environment for opposition parties.

It may be difficult to establish the ruling party’s direct involvement in every reported incident of violence. But when such incidents occur repeatedly in jurisdictions under its control, the burden of restoring public confidence rests heavily on those who wield governmental authority.

The ruling party cannot afford to respond to every allegation with denial, counter-accusation or the familiar suggestion that opposition politicians are merely seeking public sympathy. It must demonstrate that the protection of democracy takes precedence over the convenience of partisan politics.

President Bola Tinubu, as the country’s chief executive and leader of the ruling party, has a particular responsibility to set the tone. His administration must make it unmistakably clear that political violence, whether directed against the APC or its opponents, will not be tolerated.

Nigeria has come too far to allow its democratic journey to be derailed by the primitive politics of intimidation and political territorialism.

After more than two decades of uninterrupted civilian rule, the country should be deepening its democratic foundations, not struggling to guarantee the most basic freedoms associated with political participation.

The 2027 elections should be an opportunity to demonstrate democratic maturity, not another occasion to showcase our inability to manage political disagreements peacefully.

Power is temporary, but the institutions and democratic values we build should outlive every government. Those who occupy public office today must therefore understand that they are not merely defending their political interests; they are custodians of a democratic inheritance that belongs to present and future generations.

If Nigeria’s democracy is to command respect beyond its borders, it must first become a democracy in which Nigerians can freely agree, disagree, organise, campaign and vote without fear.

Anything less would be a betrayal of the promise of 1999.

Abubakar writes from Ilorin, Kwara State. He can be reached via 0805 138 8285 or marxbayour@gmail.com

QUICK SHARE:

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here